Last season, Casemiro was written off as a key player, in the 2025/26 season, Manchester United are doing worse without the midfielder on the pitch. An incredible turn of events for the 33-year-old, with his contract expiring in the summer, the United management has a real dilemma. With £350,000 a week (Capology), the Brazilian is part of the wage bill problem, where management should and must cut costs on the player side as well. In the summer, “this problem” will disappear with contract expiration, but at the same time, the statistics show that Amorim is dependent on the Brazilian legend.

Casemiro’s future is still uncertain at Old Trafford. United have the option to press the option button for another season, but then the salary conditions will follow. If an extension is negotiated, Casermio will have to accept a sharp pay cut if he chooses to continue.

READ: Scott McTominay demands Napoli sign ‘disgruntled’ ex-Manchester United teammate

Right now, it is Manchester United who need Casemiro the most. Here are the stats with and without Casemiro on the pitch:

In other words, four times the chance of Man Utd conceding goals without Casemiro on the pitch. Twice as many goals with Casemiro (has accounted for 3 himself), compared to without the Brazilian on the pitch.

If Casemiro and Manchester United end up saying goodbye at the end of the season, the impact the 33-year-old has had on United’s results will have to be factored in. The replacement must be able to deliver from the start of the season in the world’s toughest league, otherwise United will lose their momentum in midfield.

It will be a tough choice.

German Football: Liverpool scouts send enthusiastic messages to Anfield about Konstantinos Koulierakis